Download PDF A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin
Why need to be this publication A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin to read? You will never ever get the expertise and experience without obtaining by yourself there or trying by on your own to do it. For this reason, reading this e-book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin is needed. You can be great as well as proper sufficient to get how vital is reading this A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin Even you constantly check out by commitment, you can sustain on your own to have reading book habit. It will certainly be so useful and also fun then.
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin
Download PDF A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin
Why need to get ready for some days to get or obtain guide A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin that you order? Why ought to you take it if you could obtain A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin the much faster one? You could find the very same book that you order right here. This is it guide A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin that you could obtain directly after acquiring. This A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin is well known book around the world, certainly lots of people will certainly try to have it. Why do not you come to be the initial? Still puzzled with the way?
Undoubtedly, to boost your life top quality, every book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin will certainly have their particular session. However, having particular recognition will certainly make you feel more positive. When you really feel something take place to your life, often, reviewing book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin could assist you to make calmness. Is that your actual pastime? Sometimes yes, however in some cases will certainly be not exactly sure. Your choice to review A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin as one of your reading publications, could be your proper e-book to check out now.
This is not around just how a lot this e-book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin costs; it is not also about just what type of publication you really enjoy to review. It has to do with exactly what you can take and obtain from reviewing this A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin You can choose to choose various other e-book; yet, it does not matter if you try to make this e-book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin as your reading option. You will certainly not regret it. This soft data e-book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin can be your great friend regardless.
By downloading this soft file publication A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin in the on the internet web link download, you remain in the initial step right to do. This website actually supplies you simplicity of ways to get the best book, from finest seller to the brand-new launched publication. You could locate much more books in this site by visiting every link that we supply. One of the collections, A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin is among the most effective collections to offer. So, the very first you obtain it, the initial you will obtain all favorable regarding this e-book A Zionist Among Palestinians, By Hillel Bardin
A Zionist among Palestinians offers the perspective of an ordinary Israeli citizen who became concerned about the Israeli military's treatment of Palestinians and was moved to work for peace. Hillel Bardin, a confirmed Zionist, was a reservist in the Israeli army during the first intifada when he met Palestinians arrested by his unit. He learned that they supported peace with Israel and the then-taboo proposal for a two-state solution, and that they understood the intifada as a struggle to achieve these goals. Bardin began to organize dialogues between Arabs and Israelis in West Bank villages, towns, and refugee camps. In 1988, he was jailed for meeting with Palestinians while on active duty in Ramallah. Over the next two decades, he participated in a variety of peace organizations and actions, from arranging for Israelis to visit Palestinian communities and homes, to the joint jogging group "Runners for Peace," to marches, political organizing, and demonstrations supporting peace, security, and freedom. In this very personal account, Bardin tries to come to grips with the conflict in a way that takes account of both Israeli-Zionist and Palestinian aims.
- Sales Rank: #1988922 in eBooks
- Published on: 2012-06-26
- Released on: 2012-06-26
- Format: Kindle eBook
Review
"Few accounts of the struggle between two peoples, covetous of the same ancestral homeland, are as enlightening and moving." ―Howard M. Sachar, author of A History of Israel
"Will have special resonance for many Jews, Muslims, Arabs, and others, both inside and outside the Middle East, who have been exposed to efforts at dialogue, discussion, and rapprochement between everyday people, but whose efforts and voices are lost in the din of ongoing violence, brainwashing of fear and hatred, and media-loving political grandstanding. [Bardin] provides a rare first-hand account of dialogue and joint-action efforts on the ground between Israelis and Palestinians [and] brings to light unknown grassroots episodes that illustrate both the hopeful potential for coexistence and the huge obstacles that continue to plague these well-intentioned efforts." ―Neil Caplan, author (with Laura Zittrain Eisenberg) of Negotiating Arab-Israeli Peace
"[A]s a panoramic view of... peace efforts by citizens on the ground during this turbulent period, Bardin's book allows the reader some wonderful insights." ―National Catholic Reporter
"A compelling, thoughtful, and honest examination of a complex situation from a powerfully conscientious peace activist." ―ForeWord Reviews
"A Zionist Among Palestinians is a testimony to the effort to bring about change, to educate Palestinians and Israelis about one another, and to touch them one at a time." ―Jewish Book Council
About the Author
Born in Mandatory Palestine, Hillel Bardin is a founder and former board member of the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, the Rapprochement Dialogue Center, and the Jerusalem Information Center, and he has served on the board of Defense for Children International. A founder of the Shlom Yerushalayim Party, he was its authorized representative in the Jerusalem Municipal Council.
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
Hillel Bardin has been a well-known and pioneering figure among the advocates of nonviolence in Jerusalem, advocating dialogue and bottom-up peacebuilding. His effort to work for nonviolence while wearing the Israel Defense Force uniform has been truly unique.... Looking around the region at present and seeing the empowerment of civil society in popular demands for regime change, it is difficult to predict their impact on Israel.... A one-person enterprise, like that of Hillel Bardin, cannot provide a full answer, but it remains a strong source of inspiration.from the foreword
Most helpful customer reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful.
Rich and informative...
By Marianne Klimchuk
Hillel Bardin's efforts toward peace is truly remarkable. The detailed and diverse accounts of his tireless efforts (along with those on both sides) and the endless risks and roadblocks are evidence of an intelligent, dedicated and thoughtful man - a model for us all. This book not only provides a new perspective on this very complicated situation but the model of how one life dedicated to change can work to make a difference. An inspiring goal for each of us.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
Contradictions of a peace activist
By Dr. Jonathan H. Simons
In his first-hand account of his peace activism from the time of the First Intifada and until 2011, Hillel Bardin documents a remarkable series of efforts, which he initiated or was closely involved in, to bring Israelis and Palestinians together and to mitigate the ill effects of occupation. The core of Hillel's activism was the establishment of several dialogue groups between Israelis and Palestinians from Jericho, Beit Sahour, Jabel Mukabber, Deheisheh, Wadi Fukin, Husan, Nablus, and Salfit, between 1988 and 2000, most of which led to some joint pro-peace community action. In addition, he set up the Runners for Peace group which operated from September 1989 to April 1991, to try to circumvent the ban on political demonstrations. As a reserve soldier serving in Ramallah in August 1988, he tried to arrange a truce so that the Israeli army would allow non-violent demonstrations, but was jailed for his troubles for two weeks when the story got out. Hillel also saw the worst aspects of the Occupation, being one of the Israeli documenters of the Nahalin massacre of April 13, 1989.
In the 1993 Jerusalem municipal elections, Hillel was one of the founders of the bi-national Shlom Yerushalayim party that hoped to mobilize the Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem to vote for the first time, though the initiative did not get back the full backing of the Palestinian leadership, despite visiting PLO chairman Arafat in Tunis. Hillel also sought to initiate peace tourism in Jericho following the Oslo agreement, and led tours of the Jerusalem for the Jerusalem Information Center to highlight the discriminatory practices of government services to the Jewish and Arab sectors of the city. He was a key figure in a legal struggle from 1999 until a partial victory in 2011 to force the Jerusalem city government to provide obligatory free public schooling for East Jerusalem Palestinians. He led another long and ultimately unsuccessful campaign, from 2004 to 2010, to have the route of the Separation Wall changed to include the neighbourhood of Sheikh Sa'ed along with the rest of the village of Jebel Mukabber within East Jerusalem. Hillel's activism has been tireless, stubborn in the face of many obstacles, and resourceful in the sheer range and persistence of initiatives. I was involved in the Beit Sahour dialogue group from 1990 to 1995 (with a break for the academic year of 1992-93) but I was unaware of the range of Hillel's peace-seeking efforts.
I was also unaware that Hillel's bridge-building between Palestinians and Jewish Israelis began before the first intifada, when in 1978 he decided that rather than going to the police, he would approach the mukhtar of the neighbouring East Jerusalem village of Sur Bahir after his son's bicycle was reportedly stolen by youths who lived there. Even in retrospect Hillel cannot explain how or why he overcame his ingrained Jewish Israeli fear and distrust of Palestinians, leaving behind the rifle he usually carried on the rare occasions he ventured into the Palestinian areas of Jerusalem captured during the 1967 war (23). Hillel grasps the negative role of Israeli education and media, as he says `our [Jewish Israeli] children were poisoned against the Arabs from the cradle; our adults had their fears reinforced daily' (233). A little more introspection would be welcome here: what enabled Hillel to break free of such negative perceptions - his childhood in the US, his sense of decency?
In any case, the successful encounter (the bicycle was returned) in Sur Bahir lead Hillel to become a community organiser across national lines in 1985 when more of the village's farmland was being taken over by the Jewish National Fund for afforestation. His next project was to have a water supply connected to the village of Obeidiyah. Most significantly, the experience of positive contact prompted Hillel to return alone to Jericho the day after serving there as a reservist in April 1988, to find out what had happened to Wajiha, a young Palestinian woman mistakenly arrested for stone throwing whom Hillel had been assigned to guard. When Wajiha's brother-in-law Sa'ed (who had been injured by one of Hillel's comrades dispersing a mock funeral by force) told Hillel that he and all his neighbours wanted peace with Israel, a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza alongside Israel, Hillel was astounded to the point of disbelief. So, he arranged with Sa'ed and his wife Yusra to bring a group of Israelis for a dialogue in which their peaceful intention was reiterated by more Jericho residents, a message that Hillel found mind-boggling, contradicting `everything we Israelis understood about the Palestinians' as violent opponents of peace (12). The meetings continued for a while, tellingly ending after Sa'ed was arrested, beaten and held in a cage by the Israeli authorities. The dialogues in Beit Sahour that lasted until 2000 began the same year.
There is a wealth of small detail in Hillel's accounts that accentuates the delicate contingency of significant peace activism, which requires the appropriate alignment of people, connections, and political circumstances. More often than not, the conjuncture of circumstances was unfavourable. For example, when the dialogue with Nablus turned into community activism in 1992, the Israelis found that their main political ally on whom they had relied to speak on high profile events, Member of Knesset Ran Cohen, was now constrained by his party's (Meretz) membership in Premier Rabin's coalition government. Although Hillel for a short while had a helpful contact in military intelligence who facilitated permission for activities and travel, events worked against the implementation of plans for large, public events, first when a Palestinian blew himself up in the adjacent Balata refugee camp, and two weeks later when Rabin deported 415 Hamas activists to the Lebanese border. In a perfect example of the institutional complexities of the context for activism, the deal sorted out through the military intelligence officer for the travel permits was thwarted by the Civil Administration (167-69). By contrast, when it finally became possible to bring the Palestinians from Nablus for a peace march in Jerusalem on 29 August 1993, the press photograph of the event provided the perfect accompaniment to the breaking news of the Oslo accords.
Looking on back on his activist `career', Hillel engages in some critical self-reflection. Although at first he thought a single exposure to the Palestinian desire for peace would be enough to convince Jewish Israelis and overcome their fears, Hillel learned that ongoing dialogue was needed to build trust and came to think of dialogue as the basis for community activism and Israeli-Palestinian cooperation. Moreover, such activism should be determined by strategic goals, arrived at in consultation with experts, assessed for its effectiveness, and pursued through the coordination of groups and organisations. His assessment is in line with other views of Israeli peace activism, that it is too fragmented and spends too much time `putting out fires', responding reactively to events and the abuses of occupation, to set and pursue strategic goals (see, for example, Maia Carter Hallward's book, Struggling for a Just Peace, (University of Florida Press, 2011)).
There is, however, not much in the book by way of such retrospective analysis. In general, Hillel's account shows both the benefits and limitations of activism grounded in personal relations and individual initiative. On the one hand, the motivation for Hillel's peace work is often deeply personal, such as his trip back to Jericho to find out Wajiha's fate, the old Palestinian man living in a hut in Jericho who kissed Hillel when he was introduced as an Israeli seeking peace (14-15), and his deep friendship with Jalal Qumsiyeh of Beit Sahour. Hillel is also a persuasive face to face operator, effective in turning personal connections to activist advantage, such as persuading his army commander Shamai to allow him to negotiate a truce with Palestinians in Ramallah, talking Sarah Kaminker into splitting from her own party, Ratz, for the 1993 Jerusalem municipal elections, or persuading a journalist for the Good Morning, Israel programme to stay to film the picnic part of a dialogue with Salfit, not only make do with footage of complaints about the nearby settlements' sewage.
On the other hand, Hillel tends not see the power structures behind the faces he deals with. As he says, he could never understand how to get the press `to pick up on a story that had no blood on it' (19), generally being frustrated by the media's disinterest in the positive news stories that he worked so hard to make, and remaining unaware of the institutional pressures of editorial policies and news frames within which individual journalists operate. Although aware of the factional politics within Beit Sahour, Hillel `never understood' why certain initiatives such as posting peace stickers were not implemented (115), or why certain dialogue groups folded (138). Familiar with Israel's institutional discrimination against East Jerusalem Palestinians, Hillel was nonetheless `amazed that the [Israeli High] court did not jump at the chance to redress the wrong' of the city's education policy (216).
Hillel notes that `this is a book of contradictions' (240), and perhaps his own embodiment of contradictions obscures his vision of the power structures his activism, and the chances of just peace, are up against. The most obvious contradiction is that until his spell in military jail, Hillel was volunteering for reserve military service that took him to the occupied territories. The book opens with an account of the situation and incident in Jericho during which Wajiha was wrongfully arrested, in which Hillel humanizes the soldiers, drawing distinctions between their individual behavior, while the book itself is dedicated to his commander Shammai, among others.
For Hillel it's a contradiction that `the same army that carries out sadistic oppression of the Palestinians is led by officers committed to a decent end to our conflict' (240), but perhaps that is a necessary condition for the occupation to continue. Although he devoted much energy to `neutralizing' the army's obstruction of Israeli-Palestinian cooperation, including the peace runs (132), he was `overjoyed' when the military intelligence officer opened up the short-lived coordination for the Nablus events (165). Hillel identifies with the Israeli army, often referring to it by its Israeli acronym Tzahal (IDF). He is unable to understand the anger of more radical Israeli activists from the End the Occupation group about the army escort for their buses that had just been prevented from entering Beit Sahour to protest (45).
Yet, Hillel was unable to live with this internal contradiction. In one of the most poignant moments of the book, he describes the point at which, while serving in Ramallah, he handed his rifle and army shirt to another soldier as he left to join some Israeli protestors that his unit had been ordered to disperse forcefully. His commander Shammai saved him from arrest, crying as he led Hillel away from the scene (60-61). Hillel's act was immensely courageous, but there is no enlightened occupation, as we tell ourselves in the peace movement, and there are no enlightened occupiers.
Throughout his activism, Hillel was guided by a single strategy, `to bring hundreds and thousands of Israelis to ... meetings' with Palestinians (12) who `had a message of peace' that needed to be formulated `in a way my fellow Israelis could hear' (85) instead of watching the violence of stone-throwing. By 1996, he felt `that one of my basic beliefs was being undermined, namely that if the Palestinians could only reassure Israelis of their peaceful goals, and stop terrorism, our own desire for peace would lead us to reasonable compromises' (232). In other words, the main obstacle to peace is Israeli fear, while it is the Palestinians' responsibility to dissipate that fear which they struggled to comprehend (81) and which was inculcated by Israeli media and public education. Repeatedly, Hillel holds Palestinians responsible after the 1993 Oslo agreement for not feeling `a pressing need ... to send positive messages to worried Israelis ... reassuring the Israelis, who hold the key to freedom, was not on the agenda' in Nablus (184), in Beit Sahour (108), or the Palestinian Authority (203). It was up to the Palestinians to `convince us of their sincerity' but `they did not prove their readiness for peace as a top strategic priority' (237). For all his understanding of the terrible suffering of Palestinians, his heavy conscience about `our Israeli failure to protect our Palestinian friends from our own army' (130), his acknowledgement that Israeli peace activists are a marginalized minority unlike Palestinian dialogue partners who represented their whole community (231), and his closing comments that `cast-doubt on our long-held beliefs that we [Jewish Israelis] are the forces of peace while the Palestinians are the sole rejectionists' (239), Hillel never wonders whether `we' need to convince the Palestinians of our sincere desire for peace.
With the benefit of hindsight, I disagree with Hillel's strategy, though not because, as he complains of Israeli peace activists more radical than himself, I am one of those `Jews whose sympathy for the sufferings of the Palestinians renders them insensitive to, unmoved by, the persecution and oppression that have pursued our people throughout our lengthy exile' (44). The source of our fear that Hillel wanted the Palestinians to dispel is precisely in that history of persecution, not in what Hillel understands to be their reasonable sense of being threatened by Zionist colonization (231), or even in terrorism. Rather, out of deep compassion for myself and the historical suffering of the Jewish people I believe a key goal of the Israeli peace movement must be to rid ourselves of the existential fear and deep trauma that we brought with us from another place. Our insecurity began before we came to Israel/Palestine, and in fighting wars here we have also been fighting another war, a war which began earlier, somewhere else, with a different enemy who has become displaced onto the new enemy. This confusion of wars is a constitutive confusion, a confusion of traumas around which the long war of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict has been fought. We keep fighting another war against another enemy, an enemy we brought with us, an enemy that we carry within us, whom we see in all our enemies. In order to be at peace (shalom) with ourselves, to be whole (shalem), we Jewish Israelis need to take responsibility for our fear, to work through our trauma. By doing so, we can also make peace with the Palestinians.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
An enduring struggle for peace.
By Mrs. Gillian Hirsh
This book is a detailed account of one man's attempts to contribute to a peaceful settlement of
the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians living in the territories occupied by the State.
I feel, as a citizen of the
state of Israel,and as one who shares Hillel Bardin's desire to live in peace with our neighbours;
this account of the years he has spent, and continues to spend, on the slow and often disappointing struggle,
to create good relations btwen our communities, despite the politicians and the lack of trust beteen us.
Maybe reading this book will alter the view held by so many of Israel as a warring State whose people are all belligerent.
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin PDF
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin EPub
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin Doc
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin iBooks
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin rtf
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin Mobipocket
A Zionist among Palestinians, by Hillel Bardin Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar